/
1x
Proudly Canadian, obsessively Toronto. Subscribe to Toronto Life!
Food & Drink

Inside Riley’s Fish and Steak, an over-the-top new restaurant for surf and turf

It’s the sister spot to the swanky Black and Blue Steakhouse

By Erin Hershberg| Photography by Jelena Subotic
Add Toronto Life(opens in a new tab)
Copy link
The exterior of Riley's Fish and Steak

Name: Riley’s Fish and Steak Contact: 155 Wellington St. W., rileysrestaurant.ca/toronto, @rileysfishandsteak
Neighbourhood: Entertainment District Owner: Emad Yacoub (Glowbal Restaurant Group) Head chef: Scott Saunderson Accessibility: Fully accessible

Emad Yacoub, president of the massive BC-based Glowbal Restaurant Group—which brought Toronto the two-storey, 9,000-square-foot steakhouse Black and Blue—literally squeezed his way to the top. In 1984, Yacoub emigrated from Egypt to Toronto. He was only 19 years old and didn’t speak a word of English. “My first job was juicing oranges at the Harbour Castle Hilton,” he says.

Emad Yacoub at the bar inside Riley's Fish and Steak

Related: Where Black and Blue Steakhouse chef Morgan Bellis eats in Dovercourt Village

Yacoub knew early on that he wanted to work in the hospitality industry. “Being from the Silk Route, where we were constantly playing host to people from all over the world, I believe hospitality runs in my blood,” he says. He worked his way up the hotel ranks, eventually becoming chef de cuisine at the King Edward Hotel, then at Aqua. Later, he moved out west to head up Joe Fortes Seafood and Chop House in Vancouver. “I got fired from that job,” he says. “I think I had too many ideas.” Eventually, Yacoub ended up back in Toronto.

A spread of dishes at Riley's Fish and Steak

His first restaurant was a tiny café at Yonge and Gloucester called Brownstone. “I bought the business in late 1999—with help from my brother and cousin—from owners who desperately wanted out,” says Yacoub. “It cost $92,000. That’s less than what I paid for the wine fridge at Riley’s.” To get people through the door, he set up a free coffee station right on Yonge. The trick: he hid the cream and sugar at the back of the café, so people had to pass by display cases stocked with a curated selection of salads and sandwiches. The strategy worked. A year later, Yacoub opened the fine-dining spot Solo next door before being pulled back to Vancouver for personal reasons.

Advertisement
A server pours sauce over a serving of lobster pot pie

Related: A team of Toronto’s restaurant-industry heavyweights is behind Summerhill’s new seafood spot

In 2002, Yacoub opened Glowbal in Vancouver’s Yaletown, then went on to deliver hit after hit. “My plan for Toronto has always been to bring my best of the list,” he says.

Enter Riley’s Fish and Steak, a surf-and-turf restaurant with Michelin recognition at its original Vancouver location, in the former Shore Club space. “My brand had been blocked in Toronto many times by restaurant-world bigwigs, so getting this former Aisenstat spot was a win for me,” says Yacoub.

Inside, diners are treated to a kind of theatre—whole roast chickens, oversized cuts of meat and lobster pot pies are rolled out on carts, some ceremoniously carved or finished right at the table.

A martini cart
The Food

The appetizer menu is surf-forward, with things like oysters, crispy calamari, crab cakes and jumbo prawn cocktails. Even the short ribs arrive glossed in escargot butter. Show-stopping seafood towers (both hot and cold) and sharable mains—like the 36-ounce bone-in cowboy rib-eye steak or the whole roast branzino—are escorted from the kitchen to their tables like Oscar winners.

Advertisement
A server cuts open the pastry shell of a lobster pot pie
For the lobster pot pie, the crustacean is briefly steamed and the vegetables blanched separately before everything is tucked into a puff pastry shell with a rich sauce of lobster stock, whipping cream and Madagascar vanilla paste, then baked until golden

 

A server pours a spoonful of sauce tableside over a serving of lobster pot pie
For service, the pie is brought out on a cart, cut open in front of guests, and finished with a fresh sauce of peas, butter and tarragon—made over an induction burner at the table

 

A serving of lobster pot pie
Here’s what it looks like when everything is said and done. $154

 

A server pours gravy over a whole roasted chicken
Another signature sharable is the classic roast chicken—done the Riley’s way, which is to say, a bit extra. Brined for 12 to 14 hours and air-dried for another eight, the bird is then stuffed with a rich blend of foie gras, breadcrumbs and herbs before being brushed with butter. It’s roasted over a medley of vegetables—brussels sprouts, shallots, baby carrots, turnips, butternut squash—that soak up every last bit of the drippings. On the side, a deeply savoury chicken jus enriched with madeira and butter, just in case a trip to the cardiologist wasn’t already required. $85

 

Baked Alaska
The baked Alaska for-two riffs on a Black Forest cake, layered with two types of semifreddo and a black cherry gel—think brandied chocolate and a rosemary-smoked black cherry purée. The whole thing is encased in a burnt honey meringue, torched tableside (naturally) and served with a brandied amarena-and-sour-cherry compote. $36
The Drinks

The wine list ventures into both explored and still-emerging producers from Ontario, British Columbia and the old world, offering 30 by-the-glass options at any given time. The cocktails remain classic, with only a gentle twist here and there, and a roaming martini cart brings the ritual tableside.

Advertisement
The Riley's No. 1 cocktail at Riley's Fish and Steak
The bright and aromatic Riley’s No. 1 is a fresh and tropical-leaning riff on the martini. Built on a base of Belvedere vodka, it layers in pineapple, star anise and lime leaf bitters, with a touch of basil syrup for a soft, herbaceous lift. $21

 

The Yuzu Bloom cocktail at Riley's Fish and Steak
For the Yuzu Bloom, a blend of two gins (Dillon’s, Roku) gets a touch of bitterness and some herbal notes from gentian liqueur. It’s all rounded out by a hint of Dillon’s peach liqueur, then balanced and brightened with simple syrup and fresh yuzu. $21

 

A server lifts the cloche from a smoked cocktail
Nothing says “fancy cocktail” like a cloche and a plume of smoke. Here we have Riley’s smoked old fashioned, a blend of Reifel and Dillon’s rye stirred with a splash of Amaro Nonino, Angostura bitters and a touch of vanilla syrup to give it that familiar bourbon-like warmth (while the US-made spirit remains persona non grata). $23

 

Riley's Smoked Old Fashioned
Here’s the finished drink, sans smoke
The Space

At 7,800 square feet with 175-seats (not including the 100-seat patio coming soon), archways, marble, splashy millwork and a massive bar, Riley’s is a certified show-off and proud of it. It’s the kind of restaurant that makes all the others feel honoured just to be nominated.

The bar at Riley's Fish and Steak
Bar seating at a steakhouse
The dining room at Riley's Fish and Steak in Toronto
Art hangs on the walls at Riley's Fish and Steak
Marble flooring and floor-to-ceiling windows in the dining room of Riley's Fish and Steak
Booth seating in a restaurant dining room
A mirror reflects the dining room inside Riley's Fish and Steak

Erin Hershberg is a freelance writer with nearly two decades of experience in the lifestyle sector. She currently lives in downtown Toronto with her husband and two children.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Big Stories

293 Days Without My Son: I gave up everything to rescue my kidnapped child from my abusive husband

293 Days Without My Son: I gave up everything to rescue my kidnapped child from my abusive husband

Inside the Latest Issue

The June issue of Toronto Life features the best new restaurants of 2026. Plus, our obsessive coverage of everything that matters now in the city.