/
1x
Proudly Canadian, obsessively Toronto. Subscribe to Toronto Life!
Real Estate News

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

By Kelly Reid| Photography by Paul Bennett
Add Toronto Life(opens in a new tab)
Copy link
The cottage for sale at 1057 Montgomery Bay Road

Address: 1057 Montgomery Bay Road
Neighbourhood: Dwight Agent: Jay Richardson, Royal LePage Lakes of Muskoka, Brokerage Price: $1,995,000

The place

An early-20th-century log cabin built on a point of land that juts out into Lake of Bays.

The interior doesn’t have to try very hard to look rustic, because it’s actually made of tree trunks:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

The owners have updated the cottage over the years, turning it into an all-weather retreat:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

The selling agent says the kitchen is under renovation, and will be updated by the time the eventual buyers move in:

Advertisement
Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

The family room, with a view of Lake of Bays:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

There are three bedrooms. Here’s one:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

And another:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

And the last:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

The cottage is much more impressive from the back than it is from the front:

Advertisement
Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays

Obligatory drone shot:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays
DCIM105GOPRO
The history

The cottage has been in the same family for three generations; it was built by the present owner’s grandfather in 1936. The family winterized the place in 1989. In 2009, they added a sunroom.

Big selling point

The three-sided wraparound deck is huge, with lots of space for outdoor dining, and the southwest exposure lets in sun all afternoon:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays
Possible deal breaker

The cabin has been updated over the years, but the dock not so much. It’s charming in a rustic way, but anyone with yachting ambitions may need to invest in a boathouse:

Cottage of the Week: $2 million for a rustic log cabin on Lake of Bays
By the numbers

• $1,995,000 • $8,233.00 in taxes (2016) • 1500 square feet • 476 feet of waterfront • 14 acres • 3 bedrooms • 1 bathroom

Advertisement

The Hunt

More Cottages of the Week

$15.2 million for a Bala compound steps from a dark-sky preserve
Real Estate News

$15.2 million for a Bala compound steps from a dark-sky preserve

This 7,500-square-foot getaway comes with blasted granite, a rustic catwalk and a fish-cleaning station in the boathouse
Advertisement
Advertisement

The Latest

Inside the Latest Issue

The July issue of Toronto Life features the monster cottages of Muskoka versus the resistance. Plus, our obsessive coverage of everything that matters now in the city.