Removing social media is not the answer for long-term growth and development, says one educator
Walk into the bedroom of any tween or teen, anywhere in the country, and chances are pretty good that you’ll find them scrolling social media. Networks like YouTube, Instagram and TikTok have become an integral part of the experience of growing up, and given that kids today are digital natives who have never known life without the internet, you’d be hard-pressed to find a middle-schooler without at least one social media account. Even younger children who aren’t old enough to have their own accounts can navigate their way through YouTube as if they were born knowing how (we’ve all seen a toddler find episodes of Sesame Street or Bluey like a boss).
Parents and experts alike, however, worry about the effects of social media’s constant stream of entertainment on child development. It’s the age of instant gratification, where content can be changed with a tap or a swipe, so how do kids learn to focus on one thing at a time? Should educators be adjusting their lessons to accommodate? “We’re in the attention economy now, with constant demands on focus. This is true for both adults and kids,” says Alyson Schafer, a parenting expert and counsellor in Toronto. “But the reality is, parents and teachers have to teach kids to differentiate between what’s productive material and what isn’t. It’s more important than ever for kids to learn the difference, and it’s on the adults in their lives to show them.”
With this in mind, it might seem like a no-brainer to just remove social media from the classroom—many schools have a no mobile device policy on school grounds—and stick to traditional teaching methods, but many educators believe there is an opportunity with the integration of social media to teach kids to be judicious about content. “Removing social media is not the answer for long-term growth and development. We work to build a strong understanding of what social media is and what it is capable of,” says Garth Nichols, vice-principal of strategic innovation at Havergal College in Toronto. (Havergal even has a course called Digital Wisdom for students in grades 5, 6, 7 and 8!) “It’s important for students to become responsible and ethical citizens who can navigate a digitally mediated world,” says Nichols. “Our teachers work with our students on the negative and positive impacts of social media, on everything from media literacy to physical health to personal branding.” Lee Vendetti at J. Addison in Markham, Ont., agrees: “Students [need to] learn to think critically, become smart consumers of products and information, recognize points of view and identify the role of media in our culture. At J. Addison, media literacy is taught in all classes.” Schafer also adds that the application of social media matters, that it can provide valuable opportunities to contribute and to connect when used in a meaningful way. “The quality of content students are engaging with matters,” says Schafer. “There can be time well-spent on tech and social media.”
Gamification is a great example of how technology and social platforms can enhance learning. Apps or programs like Mathletics and Prodigy allow kids to take on lessons and advance through online games, or to challenge classmates in academic activities. “Gamification can increase student participation, social interaction and self-guided exploration when combined with other methods of research,” says Dave Treherne, elementary principal at Unionville Montessori in Markham, Ont. “It can allow students to reflect on their work, set their own goals and track their progress. During competitive games, teachers can identify areas of weakness, group and individual skill levels and overall engagement with a topic of study.” Gamification as an education resource can be a way to engross kids and to boost their confidence, but it should be used as part of an integrated approach to engagement. “I really think that the right program used appropriately can have tremendous value,” says Schafer. “But we do need to be able to take kids off of technology and into the real world to make sure they experience boredom, imagination, interacting at a slower pace...that’s important, too.” The name of the game is balance (like all things!). The sweet spot integrates both old school and new school learning, to teach our kids to be effective problems solvers and critical thinkers.
More from Toronto Life's Private and Independent School Guide
Generation Alpha, Gen A, The COVID Generation: Whatever you call them, and only time will tell, a new cohort of kids have arrived and already their distinct personality traits are forming. By sheer necessity to survive a pandemic, they’re proving themselves resilient, independent, passionate and—when it comes to traditional work done the old-fashioned way—outspoken and defiant. But to understand the up-and-coming Gen A, I’ll call any kid born after 2010 here, you have to first understand the...
Though economists have been discussing the rise of precarious work for years, nothing could have possibly prepared us for a global pandemic. Eighteen months later, as the economy slowly reopens, experts are beginning to see and imagine what a post-COVID economy might look like. “I don’t have a crystal ball, unfortunately,” admits U of T economy professor Elizabeth Dhuey, though the specialist in the economics of education can make a very educated guess. “Fair to say there will be a whole lot of...
Finally, some good news for students and new graduates after a long, hard few years: “Despite a mass disruption in the labour market,” explains University of Toronto economics professor Elizabeth Dhuey, “for many this equates to more opportunity.” How so? “When people feel their bosses and organization didn’t support them, they pull away. If you don’t feel like your company has your back, you’re more likely to leave.” March 2020 and beyond unfolded a lot like exposure therapy. Just as people...
Walk into the bedroom of any tween or teen, anywhere in the country, and chances are pretty good that you’ll find them scrolling social media. Networks like YouTube, Instagram and TikTok have become an integral part of the experience of growing up, and given that kids today are digital natives who have never known life without the internet, you’d be hard-pressed to find a middle-schooler without at least one social media account. Even younger children who aren’t old enough to have their own...
It will likely take decades to see and understand the full effects of remote learning on kids, but studies are already trickling in: In February, SickKids released its results of a survey asking more than 1,000 parents and nearly 360 youth how and if the pandemic had worsened their mental health. Their findings were concerning, albeit not surprising: Of six domains—depression, anxiety, irritability, attention span, hyperactivity and obsessions/compulsions—more that 70 per cent of school-aged...
Youth activism isn’t a new concept. In fact, historians can trace the involvement of young people in advocacy back hundreds of years. But with every generation, more and more adolescents and young adults have been motivated to address the issues that plague the world around them, and have led the charge for change in myriad arenas: human rights, women’s rights and reproductive rights, civil rights, education disparity, gun violence, climate change and more. Today’s youth are the most social...
NEVER MISS A TORONTO LIFE STORY
Sign up for The Vault, our free newsletter with unforgettable long reads from our archives.