“My dog met the love of his life. Then I did too”
Charley was overweight, arthritic and 91 in dog years. He didn’t know his life was about to change
Charley was overweight, arthritic and nearing the end of his life. He had embraced 13 trips around the sun—91 in dog years—and seemed to be mostly tolerating whatever time he had left. For a while, his world was confined to a patch of grass outside an overpriced steakhouse near my downtown condo, where he did his business beside a sign that read: NO DOGS.
Aside from feeling a sliver of pride in Charley’s daily act of rebellion, I wrestled with what it meant. My old dog couldn’t make the walk to the park farther down the block. This was the closest green space he could get to. He deserved more.
Although he’d started out as my family dog, I was now taking care of Charley full time. My father died of cancer a few years ago, leaving my mother alone with an aging dog. Eventually, the everyday responsibilities of walking him, feeding him and ferrying him to the vet became too much. She asked me to take custody. Charley had been my dad’s cherished companion, so claiming him felt like keeping a small piece of my father alive.
Beyond this grief-tinged responsibility, Charley and I had been through a lot together. From the wild days of my teenage years to the dawn of my thirties, this fluffy goldendoodle was woven into the fabric of my life. It felt unfair that this was how it would end: him pooping in front of a steakhouse as I dodged the judgmental gazes of passing pedestrians.
But Charley’s life was about to expand: he was about to meet someone. And so was I.
When I first met Shelley on a date at a downtown pub, we covered the usual ground—family, career, hobbies. Her face lit up when she spoke about her dog. “I know this is going to sound crazy,” she said, “but my dog is my greatest accomplishment.”
A couple of years earlier, Shelley had moved into a Toronto loft overlooking the Kay Gardner Beltline Trail, the former railway turned walking path. She chose the condo because the Beltline offered instant access to wilderness—and she knew she wanted a dog. After months of research, she brought home a six-month-old goldendoodle. Indie represented a turning point in her life, she said, a milestone of independence and responsibility that softened the transition of living alone.
On our second date, I introduced Shelley to Charley, who barrelled toward her with all his arthritic gusto. As always, Charley treated every stranger like a long-lost friend, wheezing toward them, either oblivious or indifferent to cyclists swerving out of his path. We walked along the Harbourfront, sunlight bouncing off Lake Ontario as pedestrians milled about. Eventually, fatigue got the better of him. He lay down in front of a restaurant patio, abruptly ending our walk. Shelley and I ordered nachos. There, we talked for hours.
Related: “I traded my lucrative career as a mortgage broker to shepherd goats”
After a few more dates, Shelley decided I was worthy of being introduced to her dog. “She’s very tentative,” she warned me in the hallway. But, as soon as she opened the door, Indie and I were cuddling on the ground. It was love at first sight—between me and Indie, at least.
Introducing the dogs to each other was another story. When I first brought Charley over, Indie struggled to compute this barrelling force of white fur. She watched him sniff every surface, then snapped when he snatched her tennis ball. Charley, oblivious, wagged his tail and carried on. Eventually, Charley and I began staying over more often. As time passed, something thawed between the two dogs. Indie began to accept Charley’s company—or at least tolerate it.
The real turning point came in November of last year, when Shelley and I rented a cabin outside Prince Edward County. On the ride over, Charley sprawled across the back seat, resting his head on Indie’s. She peered at Shelley in the passenger seat, as if to say, “Please remove this moron from my personal space.” But she didn’t growl at him, which we perceived as progress.
At the cabin, Charley rediscovered play. Indie chased chipmunks; Charley chased Indie. He even ate an entire mound of pizza dough when we weren’t looking—the kind of mischief he’d pulled in his youth. Together, the dogs explored the forest, burying their faces in leaves.
Those leaves, we later learned, were infested with ticks. More than we could count. Shelley spent hours pulling them off. Confronted with the dreadful task of remaining still, Indie and Charley trauma-bonded. After a course of antibiotics, they were both clear.
Four and a half months after that trip, Charley and I moved in, and the four of us became a pack. On the Beltline, the dogs achieved minor celebrity. “It’s Indie and Charley!” people would call, offering treats.
Charley, who had shed some weight and regained muscle, felt obligated to greet every walker, whether they wanted it or not. Indie, watching his fearlessness, began approaching strangers and other dogs too. (As a puppy, she’d walked around with a sign on her leash that read Do Not Pet because she was easily startled.) Shelley and I ambled behind them, holding hands.
Despite Charley’s arthritis, they played for hours in the condo. Indie leapt around, nuzzling his neck, while Charley thrashed his torso, tongue flopping. At night, they curled up on their beds, and Shelley and I drifted off to the sound of their steady breathing. Each morning, before we were fully awake, two furry faces hovered at the edge of our mattress.
But, during a routine check-up, our vet, Josh—an old friend from high school—broke some bad news. There was a tumour on Charley’s spleen. “It might be time,” he said gently, “to start thinking about how you want to say goodbye.”
Charley was almost fourteen. But Josh’s words cleaved through whatever preparation I thought I’d done.
What haunted me wasn’t that Charley would die but how suddenly it could happen. Josh warned that the tumour could rupture at any time. He’d go from happily trotting down the Beltline to collapsing in pain. I couldn’t allow that.
As he panted by my feet, I remembered a game I used to play with my dad. We’d hug tightly, backs turned to Charley, and it would become a sort of competitive dance where we both tried to twist each other toward two paws scrambling for affection. These days I couldn’t hug the man, so I hugged the dog. I wasn’t ready to let him go.
I couldn’t prevent Charley’s death forever, but I couldn’t let it come so abruptly. Not when his world had grown again. Not when he had Indie. Shelley encouraged me to do what I could. Expensive tests revealed that the tumour wasn’t cancerous, but it was still a threat. Josh moved quickly, scheduling surgery within days.
Charley came home shaved, stitched and loopy, but he pulled through. A few days later, he was back on the Beltline beside Indie.
That September, I proposed to Shelley on a canoe trip in Algonquin Park. Somewhere along the journey of forming our pack, she became the partner I wanted to build a family with. I found a west-facing campsite, scattered rose petals from my mother’s garden and built a fire as the sun set. Indie sat beside us, head bowed, as if officiating.
We knew Charley couldn’t manage the long paddles, the slippery landings, the uneven terrain. It was the first trip we’d taken without him. As I knelt on one knee, Indie’s presence offered a bittersweet reminder: she represents our future. My old dog represents my past.
Yet, for a brief overlap, the future and the past walked together down the same trail. Leaves carpeted the Beltline. A few more snowfalls blanketed the ground. Charley and Indie galloped through it all.
Then, one December night, we took Charley to an emergency animal hospital. His gums were swollen. He was lethargic and dizzy. Indie had tried to play with him, but he’d refused. I knew something was up. A night-shift veterinarian told us there was some fluid build-up around his heart. She asked us to consider our options—ending his life peacefully or having him hang on with the likelihood of greater suffering inching closer. It was now time to make the right choice, not for me but for him.
With Charley hooked up to an oxygen mask, fluorescent lights buzzing overhead, Indie said goodbye to her friend, the machines humming as she sniffed his face. Shelley kissed his ear. I ran my hands along his body, listening to the air whizzing through a vent, the beeping of a monitor, the mechanical ambience of death, something I was no stranger to witnessing.
He pulled through that night, and the next morning, he greeted us with his usual tail-thumping enthusiasm, as if nothing had happened. It was jarring to see him walking around after he had been hooked up to an oxygen mask the previous night. But we were told the fluid around his heart would return—if not in days then in hours.
Shelley brought his bed. My mother and sister came to the animal hospital. We gathered around him, trying to make sure Charley was comfortable as he drifted off into a dream he would not awake from.
Some people will never understand grief over a dog: to them, it is just an animal, a pet succumbing to the inevitable. Those people don’t resonate with muddy paws, drool-doused toys and finding the occasional dog hair in your food. As I said goodbye, I thought about how the people we are when we bring home a dog are never the ones who give them their final kisses. Within their short lives, dogs are witnesses to our best days and worst days, our triumphs and heartbreaks, our joy and grief. Through it all, they watch our transformation.
One day soon, Shelley and I will bring home a new puppy, and Indie will be our older dog. We’ll brace to feel this pain all over again. That’s the price two dog lovers are prepared to pay.
Knowing this, I think about how love—in all its forms—is really just the willingness to keep walking together, even when one of you starts to slow down.
