Advertisement
Food & Drink

What’s on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar’s new American sister spot across the street

By Caroline Aksich| Photography by Caroline Aksich
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street

Name: Poor Romeo Contact: 1029 Gerrard St. E., @poor_romeo_bar
Neighbourhood: Leslieville Owners: Marc Baglio, Adam Graham and Andy Wilson (Pinkertons) Chef: Andy Wilson (Pinkertons)

The food

Where Pinkerton’s menu skews Asian, Poor Romeo’s—with snacks like nachos with cheese dip, cornbread salad and fried green tomatoes—is an all-American affair. Smashed burgers and buttermilk fried chicken sandwiches are complemented by some fancier stuff, like a whole roasted sea bream, sourced from Hooked, and served with fingerling potatoes, pickled cabbage and brussels sprouts.

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
Cheddar jack “cheez” sauce with corn chips. (Wilson wanted to get it as close to the texture of movie-theatre cheese dip as possible.) $8.

 

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
Two gorditas come stuffed with chorizo (made in-house using pork from Olliffe), potatoes and queso fresco. $9.

 

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
For this sandwich, chicken thigh is dredged in an Old Bay– and paprika-spiked flour mixture before being tossed in the fryer. It’s served on a buttered potato bun with slaw. $13.

 

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
Four-ounce patties (a mix of chuck and fatty brisket) are seared, smashed on the flat-top, stuffed inside house-made potato buns and topped with shredded iceberg lettuce, “special sauce” and American cheese. $12.

 

Advertisement
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
Whole roasted sea bream from Hooked is topped with chimichurri and chilies, and served with fingerling potatoes, pickled cabbage and brussels sprouts. $MP.

 

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
There are oysters, too.

 

The drinks

A short list of signature cocktails with cheeky names, and a selection of craft (Bellwoods, Woodhouse, Left Field) and grandpa (Molson, Coors) beers. The 10 taps change weekly, while the cans and bottles come exclusively in short and stubby formats, respectively.

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
From left to right: the Gin Lizzy, made with gin, Aperol, St. Germain, citrus and egg white ($13); the Beast of Bourbon, a shandy remake with bourbon, whisky, lemon simple syrup and some Molson Stock Ale ($13); and a boozy, three-rum piña colada from the on-site slushie machine ($13).

 

The space

It took a whole bunch of elbow grease to rehabilitate this 40-seat room, previously Ruyi Chinese Restaurant. Two flat-screens above the bar are covered up by barn board doors at 10 p.m. “We want to have a neighbourhood bar vibe, but we don’t want to be a sports bar,” says Graham.

What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street
Graham (left) wants to preserve Ruyi’s history by hanging the original sign in the bar.

 

Advertisement
What's on the menu at Poor Romeo, Pinkerton Snack Bar's new American sister spot across the street

NEVER MISS A TORONTO LIFE STORY

Sign up for Table Talk, our free newsletter with essential food and drink stories.

By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.
You may unsubscribe at any time.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Caroline Aksich, a National Magazine Award recipient, is an ex-Montrealer who writes about Toronto’s ever-evolving food scene, real estate and culture for Toronto Life, Fodor’s, Designlines, Canadian Business, Glory Media and Post City. Her work ranges from features on octopus-hunting in the Adriatic to celebrity profiles.

Advertisement
Advertisement

More New Restaurants

What’s on the menu at Bar Maaya, a moody new lounge serving over-the-top cocktails

What’s on the menu at Bar Maaya, a moody new lounge serving over-the-top cocktails