/
1x
Proudly Canadian, obsessively Toronto. Subscribe to Toronto Life!
Food & Drink

Canadian comedian opens a coffee shop called Dumb Starbucks; could go to jail

Add Toronto Life(opens in a new tab)
Copy link
Canadian comedian opens a coffee shop called Dumb Starbucks; could go to jail
(Image: Dumb Starbucks/Facebook)

Vancouver comedian Nathan Fielder made headlines earlier in the week when he opened a coffee shop called Dumb Starbucks in a Los Angeles strip mall. Everything about the place looked identical to a Starbucks outlet—from the circular logo to the menu—except for the addition of the word “Dumb.” The attention-grabbing gag worked: people lined up for hours to sample Dumb Frappucinos and Dumb Iced Coffees, and the story was reported around the world.

Now it looks like the price for insta-fame might be pretty steep. Fielder casually revealed on Jimmy Kimmel Tuesday night that he may, in fact, be facing jail time for the stunt. While the use of Starbucks’ name and logo is apparently legal under “parody law,” serving mediocre coffee and store-bought baked goods without the proper health permits is not. Just days after opening, the Los Feliz shop was shut down by L.A. police. Fielder’s defense for operating without permits? He claims Dumb Starbucks isn’t a real coffee shop, it’s an art gallery. “What they don’t understand is that legally, we are an art gallery and the coffee we are selling is considered the art, and galleries don’t need health permits.”

Unfortunately for Fielder, the Health Board doesn’t see it that way. He met with the board on Tuesday, and discovered that the penalty for serving food without permits is actually pretty harsh. “I really just found this out that the penalty is up to six months in jail—so we are trying to be very nice to them,” he told Kimmel. Either way, Fielder doesn’t seem too concerned. In fact, he’s already looking at expanding the franchise. The video promo for Dumb Starbucks is embedded above, and Fielder’s Jimmy Kimmel appearance is below.

Jean Grant has been a freelance writer since 2015, covering a range of lifestyle topics like shopping, interiors, wellness and culture for publications like Maclean’s and Toronto Life. She also enjoys working with brands to develop custom content, and shares personal essays through her Substack newsletter, Nobody is Thinking About You.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Big Stories

293 Days Without My Son: I gave up everything to rescue my kidnapped child from my abusive husband

293 Days Without My Son: I gave up everything to rescue my kidnapped child from my abusive husband

Inside the Latest Issue

The July issue of Toronto Life features the monster cottages of Muskoka versus the resistance. Plus, our obsessive coverage of everything that matters now in the city.