In September’s cover story, long-time Toronto Life contributor Philip Preville explores the idea that Toronto is a hostile place for young families—prompting some to move to the new belt of exurbs in places like Dundas, Cobourg, and Port Hope—and attempts to figure out why these small towns hold such appeal for people who were once diehard downtowners. The article has stirred up more than a little reaction, and we’ll be the first to admit that not all of it has been positive. But that’s what quality conversation is all about. A list of some of the strongest critiques of Preville’s piece, after the jump.
• One of the earliest reactions came from the National Post’s Peter Kuitenbrouwer, who writes that he had a hard time buying the claim that the urban refugees featured in the story “discovered a paradise of warm interpersonal mingling, a kind of Disney hometown where you ‘say your hellos and inquire about others and share news readily.’”
• John Lorinc probably wins the prize for most acid reaction, writing in Spacing that the article didn’t break any news, while lamenting the “inexcusably coarse” choice of words in the display copy (“Screw Jane Jacobs. We’re outta here”). The rest—well, it should be read on its own (along with the comments).
• The husband-and-wife team of Ed Keenan and Rebecca Cuneo Keenan each penned a reaction to Preville’s piece—but both argued, contra Preville, that they never felt like Toronto was all that unfriendly or hostile. Cuneo Keenan hammers away at the point that perhaps security and freedom are in the eyes of the beholder.
• Even more interesting than Ed Keenan’s take was the debate he and Preville engaged in over Twitter last night. Keenan cited the work that Adam Vaughan had been doing to make sure that the new condos going up in his ward are family-friendly (in other words, that they have more than two bedrooms). We’ve captured most of that conversation here.
• Preville also appeared on CBC’s Metro Morning, where Matt Galloway took being called an “ossified propagandist” pretty well, all things considered.
• Regular Toronto Life contributor Denise Balkissoon asks: what about diversity? What about economics?
• And finally, Torontoist parodied the September issue cover, and all we can say is ouch!
Also, check out the Twitter hashtag #unfriendlytoronto for stories of Toronto being warmer than is often believed.
• Peter Kuitenbrouwer: Peterborough Life, anyone? [National Post]
• Toronto Life screws Jane Jacobs? [Spacing Toronto]
• A suburb by any other name… [The Grid TO]
• The City’s No Place To Raise Kids, says Toronto Life. I’m Not Buying It. [Playground Confidential]
• The New Exurbanites: comments on this month’s Toronto Life [Digested]
• Glad Hand: The Ossified Opinion is Always Greener [Torontoist]