Blogs

Chatto’s Digest

French Caviar

Posted on June 26, 2006

I’m sitting here mulling over comments posted by lunchbill about last week’s blog, a report of an evening at Michael Stadtländer’s Eigensinn Farm. “What’s to get,” asks lunchbill, “the co-opting of nature and country life by an elitist, wealthy, urban culture? Some people do get ‘it’ and realize that some other people need to return to reality.” I’m not sure if he/she objects to Stadtländer (born and raised on a farm near Lubeck) owning and working his farm in Ontario and subsidizing the operation by feeding people in his dining room, or if the problem is people from the city going out into the countryside in order to eat. I don’t see anything particularly reprehensible in either scenario. It seems to me Stadtländer did return to an earthy, honest reality when he gave up the urban rat race and started farming organically 13 years ago. And I can’t think of a less elitist human being than Michael—artist, social activist and environmentalist, yes, but not elitist.

I hope lunchbill won’t think I’m taunting her/him if we now turn our thoughts to a very elite treat—caviar. Ever since CITES, the U.N. Convention on International Trade of Endangered Species that controls the industry, imposed a much-needed moritorium on international trade in all Caspian Sea caviar, sturgeon caviar has been in very short supply. Chefs and others who love the stuff have tried to keep track of the progress of sturgeon farms in the U.S. and Europe and have striven to get their hands on any of the wild Canadian sturgeon caviar coming out of Abitibi. Marché Transatlantique, a Quebec firm, has the best of the Abitibi product, provided by a 77 year-old fisherman in the north of the province. It’s freshwater sturgeon and therefore tastes different from Caspian caviar but the riverbeds there are clean stones, not mud, and the flavour of the roe is excellent.

Now the same company is importing farmed caviar from Aquitaine in the southwest of France. There used to be wild sturgeon in France until the 1950s when overfishing wiped out the species. In the 1980s, French and Soviet scientists worked together to try and introduce Siberian sturgeon (Acipenser baeri) to the Gironde, Dordogne and other rivers, but without success. As part of the process, however, they did figure out how to breed these sturgeon in captivity and the first French sturgeon farms were established in 1992. It takes a decade for a female sturgeon to reach sexual maturity, but today there are four major operations there farming (this year) a total of 12 tons of caviar—which makes France the world’s biggest caviar producer.

Bruno Marie, president of Marché Transatlantique, tried the French roe six years ago and thought it was terrible. Three years later, processing and salting techniques had dramatically improved and Marie saw a future for the product in Canada. It has taken him another three years to secure the rights to import it, but now the first shipment is here, CIFA approved. The eggs are dark-grey to black in colour, about the size of sevruga. They’re soft but by no means mushy and have a deliciously rich flavour with a bittersweet note that lasts and lasts on the palate. If you want some, phone Marché Tranatlantique at 1-800-394 3530. The French caviar costs $55 for 30 grams and ships by courier overnight.

Comments

Neither James Chatto nor Toronto Life necessarily agree with the comments posted below. Read our full policy

You must have a Torontolife.com account to post comments. If you do not have an account you can register now.

bacchus June 29, 2006 at 11:21 p.m.

A question regarding Eigensinn Farm,

Why did you choose this out of town restaurant as the top of 20 TORONTO restaurants when in fact is an out of town restaurant? Is this restaurant/house genuinely on the same field as toronto restaurants? Or is it very much location driven? As a devoted reader of your colums this confused me very much.

Thanks


lunchbill June 30, 2006 at 3:34 p.m.

No doubt Stadtländer & Co. are wonderful people, with fine intentions, but $300/person meals, without wine, are elitist. Add the inconvniences associated with Eigensinn (the travel, the need for local accommodation, the dictated start time and menu) and it becomes even more so. The farm is the traditional domain of the peasant. Let's not pretend that this is in any way a real farm. It's Susur with mosquitoes, social activism for investment bankers.

and btw, I love caviar!


jchatto July 5, 2006 at 11:59 a.m.

Hi Bacchus
Every other year or so, the Toronto Life Top 20 (or 10 or whatever format the annual awards might take) spreads a net that falls beyond the actual city to include the area generally covered by Toronto Life's restaurant guide. In other words, it includes restaurants in our Out of Town section. Eigensinn Farm is definitely in this group as are restaurants in, say, Prince Edward County, Niagara, Stratford, etc. The same criteria of judgement apply to out of town restaurants as to restaurants in the GTA. The top 20 is a personal list and last year I felt the meal I had at Eigensinn was the most exciting culinary experience of my year. Hope that answers your question.


jchatto July 5, 2006 at 12:10 p.m.

Dear lunchbill,
I guess we'll have to disagree on what constitutes a farm. And on what constitutes a farmer. The word peasant is loaded with meanings that don't really apply to this century or country and certainly don't reflect the sociopolitical group of any farmer I know. They don't tend to live in fealty to feudal overlords, unless you count the banks. It's true that Eigensinn Farm is inconveniently placed for Torontonians and yes, it sure is expensive. Maybe the price makes it elitist, but I've always thought elitism was more a matter of attitude than money.


Chatto Bio Pic

James Chatto

James Chatto worked as a dishwasher, actor, waiter, bow tie salesman, choreen, bookseller, nanny, tennis coach, lounge singer, KFC truck driver (fired after 1 day), olive farmer and janitor before moving to Canada in 1987 and becoming a journalist. These days, he writes about food and restaurants for Toronto Life, about wine and spirits for Food & Drink and edits the menswear magazine, Harry. Two of his books are still in print: A Matter of Taste (co-written with Lucy Waverman) and The Greek For Love, a memoir of Corfu. James is married and has two delightful children.

Chatto's Digest RSS Feed